Nutrition for High Performance: Carbohydrates are Good

Nutrition-for-High-Performance-Carbohydrates-are-Good
Amelia Phillips

Posted by

Share this article

Editors Note: This is a guest post from Olympic Athlete Michael Blackburn, BAppSci (Hons), PhD (Sports Science).

I’m writing this because too many times I’ve heard from athletes that ‘sugar is bad’ or ‘sugar makes me fat’. So I wanted to talk about some facts regarding the benefits of carbohydrates/sugars in an athlete’s diet.

With so many messages about diets in the general media it’s important for athletes to remember that they need an eating plan that provides high quality energy for training and competition, rather than follow diet fads of the general population.

Firstly, some important background.

There are 3 primary energy sources for the body – carbohydrates, fat, protein. Note the energy (kilojoules) in each gram of these macronutrients:

Carbohydrate -16 kj/gram
Fat – 37 kj/gram
Protein – 17 kj/gram
(Alcohol – 29 kj/gram)
(1 calorie = 4.18 kilojoules)

So you’ll take in about the same energy when you eat 2 grams of a pure carbohydrate food as 1 gram of fat.

To gain weight, the total energy obtained from food should be greater than energy expended. Conversely, to loose weight, the balance between intake and expenditure will be negative. It’s just maths.

There are some tricks, of course.

Typically, carbohydrate foods are more easily digested and somewhat less satisfying that fatty foods, hence the ease with which we can consume excessive amounts of carbohydrates and blame them for getting fat. Also for every gram of carbohydrate stored, 3 grams of water are needed. This adds weight, but is useful during training to maintain hydration.

An alternative route to the thinking that carbohydrates are bad is the ‘hidden’ fat that often accompanies meals seen as ‘carbohydrates’. For instance, on the surface a pasta meal is primarily carbohydrate and therefore relatively energy sparse. However, the addition of oil, sauces or other ingredients can easily skew the ratio of the macronutrients toward the fatty end and provide an abundance of kilojoules… and fat on the hips. Remember, energy balance and the gaining or loosing of weight is just maths.

What and Where: Carbohydrates for Athletes

Total carbohydrates are made up of simple sugars, complex carbohydrates, and fiber.

Simple carbohydrates are commonly known as sugars. Sources of simple carbohydrates include sugar, lollies/candies, soft drinks/sodas and bakery goods. These foods are low on vitamins and minerals and it’s usually best to only eat them just after training or competition, when the body is starving for quick carbohydrates (those with a high Glycemic Index ).

Complex carbohydrates include all the complex starches and fiber, such as those found in grains, cereals, breads and starchy vegetables like potatoes, corn, peas and beans. Milk, fruit and vegetables also contain some carbohydrate.

Complex carbohydrates contain many essential nutrients and are the body’s most effective source of fuel to the athlete. Complex carbohydrates are ideal because they are rapidly digested and absorbed into the bloodstream.

Carbohydrates should make up the largest portion of the athlete’s diet. Research suggests that to maintain adequate carbohydrate stores during heavy training, carbohydrate intake should be 7-10 grams/kg of body weight/day or 55-70% of energy from carbohydrate.

Endurance athletes who train heavily on successive days, or who compete in very long endurance events, would benefit from a diet that has 65% – 70% of total kilojoules from carbohydrates. Sprinters, weight lifters and other power and sprint athletes can train effectively on slightly less carbohydrates (and more protein).

Fat intake for athletes, as well as healthy adults, should comprise less than 30% of total calories. Protein intake should be about 15% – 20% of daily kilojoules (and a little more for strength and power athletes).

These days, many food labels carry the macronutirent ratio (carbs-fats-protein) to help you make informed choices (eg, 55:25:20).

Why Carbohydrates are Great for the Athlete

There are two main facts why carbohydrates are so important for athletes:

  • The brain runs exclusively on sugar.
  • The muscles’ preferred source of energy is sugar.

And if you need more evidence, consider these quotes from sports nutrition books, journals and websites:

  • In short-burst, high-intensity events such as sprinting, jumping and pole vaulting, carbohydrates provide 100 percent of energy (www.pioneerthinking.com).
  • Carbohydrates are the body’s favorite fuel (www.healthcastle.com).
  • Carbohydrates spare muscle from being broken down as an energy source (Eating on the Run ).
  • The time to exhaustion during endurance exercise is directly related to the initial levels of stored glycogen (carbohydrates) in the muscles (Practical Applications in Sports Nutrition ).
  • Sugar is a carbohydrate that fuels, not poisons, the muscles (Nancy Clark’s Sports Nutrition Guidebook ).
  • Adding more carbs to a generally healthy diet should boost immunity as well as athletic performance (fastertomorrow.com) .
  • Consuming 30-60 g carbohydrate? per hour during sustained intensive exercise attenuates rises in stress hormones such as cortisol and appears to limit the degree of exercise-induced immune depression (Journal of Sports Sciences ).
  • Time to exhaustion during cycling at 70% effort was 32% longer in a group that took in carbohydrates during exercise compared with a group that did not (Journal of Applied Physiology ).
  • So there you have it – don’t be afraid of carbohydrates – they’re on your side!
  • Obviously, this post is heavily biased towards carbohydrates. Athletes also need fat and protein to fulfill total nutrient requirements and follow a sound nutrition plan to support their training.If you’ve like to find out exactly what’s in the foods you eat check out Nutrition Data

    Post by Michael Blackburn, BAppSci (Hons), PhD (Sports Science). Michael has won two World Titles, competed in three Olympics in Sailing (winning a Bronze medal) and coached at a fourth (2008). Michael also writes for his Sports Training Blog.

Tags: , , , ,

  • http://blog.freefitnesstips.co.uk/what-are-carbohydrates.html Tom Parker

    Good post Amelia. However, I don’t fully agree with everything you say.

    First, whilst sugar itself is not inherently bad and can be used as a quick energy source when blood sugar levels are low it can cause numerous problems. When you consume monosaccharides and disaccarides (the two types of simple sugar) they are digested and released into the blood very quickly which then causes a surge in blood sugar levels. Your body reacts to this surge by releasing extra insulin. The overall result of this is that your blood sugar levels spike and crash very quickly which can result in rapidly fluctuating energy levels, poor appetite control (hence the reason you crave more when you eat a chocolate bar), increased fat storage and even organ damage. Therefore, there is some validity to the statements at the start of your article ‘ sugar is bad’ and ‘sugar makes me fat’.

    Secondly, the better carbohydrate choices (fruits, vegetables etc) are generally rich in vitamins, minerals, fibre and contain some water. So even if 55% to 70% of your diet comes from these sources the actual amount of carbohydrates you are getting is less.

    I still agree with your general message. Carbohydrates are not bad and should be a part of everyone’s diet. However, the quality of the carbohydrate is very important.

  • http://www.ameliaburton.com.au Amelia Burton

    Hi Tom,
    The article is directed mainly at high performance athletes, from physical athletes to performers on stage and a lesser extend highly stressed business people. Often these people DO need an ‘instant’ sugar hit, and due to the body’s high demand for sugar at that given moment, the requirement for insulin to convert sugar for storage is minimized.

    For example a marathon runner needs to consume large amounts of sugar (30-60g carbohydrates) every hour or so to maximize performance or their body will fatigue much faster as they cannot store the amount of sugar they need.
    On another interesting note, it has been documented that fructose (sugar from fruit) breaks down slower than glucose and sucrose, so many athletes prefer glucose based carbs such as jellybeans, rather than raw fruit during performance.
    But for the average punter, I completely agree that carbs need to be consumed on a much more limited basis and in as natural a form as possible to prevent that insulin spike.
    Great comment!
    Amelia

  • http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thoOxPmdZ4o youtube.com

    I like the helpful info you provide in your articles.

    I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I’m quite sure I’ll learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  • http://www.pathikshah.com/blog/install-ios-4-3-on-iphone-ipod-touch-ipad/ Hugo

    The major question in your thoughts at this time have to be does trilastin operate?